top of page

Back to:

Home        Incidents  

Planning Committee transcript, 14 Oct 2026

Andrew Waller
6 hours ago
49 min read

Edited Transcript of YouTube video of Bristol City Council Planning Committee B on 14 October 2026 (the second meeting): Planning application 26/11841/F for change of use of former St Joseph’s care home at Cotham Hill, Bristol, to student accommodation.

 

Notes:

1.     This is the YouTube transcript, edited by Andrew Waller, The Noise Pages (www.thenoisepages.com). I have removed unnecessary timestamps and “ums”, “ers” and other verbal tics, including duplicated words and phrases, and used ellipses (...) for significant deletions. Where the speaker’s continuity broke down, I have usually used a dash (—). Anything inserted for clarity is within square brackets. Reasonable care has been taken to ensure accuracy.

 

2.     If you make use of this text and wish to quote any individual, please check the relevant section of the transcript against the original video. The responsibility for accuracy is yours. Timestamps are included to help you. 

 

3.     The meeting was chaired by Councillor Don Alexander, supported by a member of the council’s Democratic Services section, identified as Officer (DS). Two planning officers made presentations and answered questions.

 

4. The YouTube video is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVlzdLwp6c4

 

2:30

Chair: Okay. Thank you. Declarations of interest.

We have none. Okay. Thank you.

I think it'd be helpful at this point if I reminded members of the committee that you should arrive at this meeting without being predetermined regarding any of the applications on the agenda.

 

That means that you come here with an open mind obviously having read the papers and the public forum etc, done all the study you can possibly do, but you should retain an open mind and be willing to listen to what you hear in this committee and not come here with a fixed decision. I would also say that you should give that appearance to outsiders. This committee and its sister committee, the Planning Committee A have been referred to as the shop window of the council. Many people look to see this committee as a reflection of the way that this council is run. And so I would expect the behaviors in this committee, including the appearance of nonpredetermination, to be taken very seriously by everybody. Thank you.

 

... we have no declarations of interest. Minutes of the previous meeting. Are there any amendments or do I have a seconder?

 

4:14

Chair: To approve ... Councillor Eddy seconds to approve. Thank you very much. Nothing on the action sheet. We now have a report on appeals which councillors may like to ask a question but also Jonathan may like to highlight something, I don't know.

 

4:34

Officer (Dymond): Thank you, chair. Yes, just briefly on appeals just in terms of sort of the general picture here, we only have three decisions that we've received recently that have been reported in the papers. There's two appeals dismissed and one allowed.

... in terms of what's coming in as well, appeals being lodged, we are noticing a little bit of an uptick there. That's in part due to some digital advertising appeals. So these are appeals against refusals of digital screens that, yeah, will be working their way through the system. And more generally again we continue to keep a close eye on appeal performance. We observe that our performance in defending appeals has and also continues to be strong. And on this and in relation to the enforcement item as well, it may be of note that we have a performance update coming to the Economy and Skills Committee soon where we'll include some more commentary on this and also the wider work within the service. Thank you.

 

5:43

Chair: Thank you. Do councilors have any questions on that? No. Oh, Richard, sorry.

 

5:50

Eddy: One question for Jonathan, a subsequent one for the chief planner, please. Jonathan, obviously with appeal decisions we're very much in the lap of the planning inspectorate. Of course, there are only three this time. I seem to recall, there's usually between half a dozen and a score or so. I assume that's purely down to — well, you mention some computer glitches — but also we haven't heard, so there may be more reported the next time.

 

6:31

Officer (Dymond): I think in terms of the decisions that we are receiving, I mean, one potential reason for why we are seeing fewer at the moment is because the inspectorate in considering those appeals will have to take account of the new NPPF.

 

That may potentially be an explanation and normally where there is a significant change in policy, as we've seen, the inspectorate may write to interested parties to seek their views on any potential policy changes before proceeding to make their decision. So that could be a potential reason for why we've seen fewer coming through recently.

 

7:15

Eddy: And thank you for that. One question to the chief planner, please. Jonathan mentioned the NPPF. I understand the planning minister has recently written to the planning inspector and copied all the inspectors regarding this and the way we should actually [?accord] to it. Could you give us a brief verbal summary and then perhaps it would be possible to write to all planning committee members in due course?

 

7:48

Simone Wilding, Chief Planner: You're right. The planning minister has written to the planning inspectorate drawing to their attention the new NPPF and particularly highlighting the increased weight that is to be given to housing developments, but also more generally — that having been the intention behind the new NPPF — that he's basically ... substantial weight is to be given, and that this has increased the tilt in the tilted balance that there was already before.

 

I can, yes, if that helps, I can circulate certainly the link to the letter and — but basically [it] just reiterates or reminds all decision makers, like, although it's addressed to the planning inspectorate, it's intended — because clearly the NPPF applies to all decision makers, so committees, officers, everybody — that the national policy framework requires us to give substantial weight particularly to, you know, where housing development is taking place in a brownfield, in an urban setting, and that is basically what he's drawing attention to, amongst other things.

 

9:10

Eddy: Thank you, Simone. One, just, supplementary, if I may: At the last meeting of the planning users group we both attended, you were asked a question from — and I'm not sure whether it was an agent or architect — who said what was the hierarchy of the various documents? And I believe you stated attention to the NPPF was at the top of the hierarchy. Is that the case?

 

9:46

Wilding: I would say so, yes, because it's the most recent up-to-date policy that, you know, that has been issued. Our emerging local plan is not yet even adopted and unfortunately we still haven't heard from the planning inspectorate actually on the final letter, when we can adopt it. So that remains not in a fully adopted state and therefore can only attach limited weight. Clearly the extant local plan is super-old. Therefore, also very limited weight. ... Therefore in this context, absolutely, the NPPF, you know, is in a way a very significant material consideration.

 

10:33

Chair: Thank you both for raising that. We have also an enforcement report. Anything, Jonathan, you want to highlight or any questions from members?

 

10:38

Officer (Dymond):  Thank you, chair. Yeah just in terms of an update on this that may be of interest for the committee. We've well the enforcement lead now has now started with us. he started earlier in September. So they report to the chief planner and working alongside myself and other leads for building control and planning policy. so that's good news. The structure and and capacity of that team is evolving. We've also recently been joined by a new starter in the team at senior level and we are hoping to undertake some additional recruitment as well soon. again I mentioned the update that's imminent for the economy and skills committee. Again that will also cover an update on enforcement as well. But I just wanted to mention that this afternoon. Thank you.

 

Chair: Thank you. When is that report coming to economy and skills?

 

11:39

Officer (Dymond):  so the meeting is the 2nd of November.

 

11:41

Chair: 2nd of November. If anyone wants to look at our PL enforcement planning enforcement strategy and meet the new leader of that group function within the council then I think that would be a good meeting to come along to really bring your questions. Thank you very much. Any questions from counselors? No. Great. Then we move on to the two items on our agenda. In these meetings we take the public forum questions and statements before each item. So I will now take public forum questions for our first item which is St. Joseph's at 66 Cotham Hill, Bristol.

 

As usual, I apologise if I mispronounce anyone's name. I do my best. ... the questions are all in the, as other statements are, ... the paper pack online. And the responses from officers to the questions are also there online for you to view. But those questioners who are here will have a chance to ask two supplementary questions and our first person today is Mr. Andrew Waller, I believe.

 

13.05

Andrew Waller: Chair, I'm speaking for Redland and Cotham Amenities Society. In answer to one of the questions I raised—this was about the Pollution Control response on the St. Joseph's application—the officers say in their reply that Pollution Control read the noise impact assessment carefully and agreed with it. I'm interested in that because neither of Pollution Control’s reports actually say that. So, I was just wondering is Pollution Control here today to tell us from the horse's mouth what they thought?

 

13:48

Mark Curtis, Pollution Control: Yeah, I am here today.

 

13:50

Chair: Yes, we do have. Thank you very much. Thank you to all the officers. We’ve got a good number of officers here to support us in our decision making today. So ... before anyone leaves, I want to say thank you to you for all coming out. It's a big part of us making sound decisions here that you're present with us. Thank you. Thank you.

 

Curtis: Did you want me to answer?

 

14:13

Chair: Yeah. Yes, please.

 

Curtis: Yeah. It's unusual for us to really sort of have a noise assessment per se for a PBSA, a purpose-built student accommodation. The assessment mainly looks at plant noise from the accommodation but gives us guidance noise levels that should be complied with there. It also looks at noise from the common room and as the report states it assumes that the common room may have some music. There's nothing in the application to say that the common room is going to be used for musical entertainment or anything is going to happen there at all. So, I think the report has just taken it upon itself to make an assessment of noise from music in the common room, which if at a reasonable level, the report concludes that it wouldn't cause any harm to neighbouring properties. I think one of the things which was raised was noise from the garden area, which clearly can cause noise to neighbouring properties but would be particularly difficult to sort of have any particular concise noise assessment of ... the garden could be used by one, could be used by several people who could be acting quietly or could be acting more boisterously, so it's something which I don't find is really particularly useful to have a environmental noise report on, and that, as well as with noise from the common room, I feel are much better dealt with through the management of the premises and the management plan, which [is] based on the management strategy which is given in the application.

 

15:52

Chair: Thank you. Mr. Waller, is that ... any further questions?

 

15:56

Waller: If I could use my second supplementary since Pollution Control is here. Was Pollution Control asked to evaluate cumulative harm? And if so, what conclusion did you come to?

 

16:13

Curtis: I think that's sort of answered in the question. We wouldn't generally look at cumulative harm there, and I find it difficult to look at the cumulative harm of that particular type of use.

 

So, in this situation, if I was looking at cumulative harm, I would look at the number of PBSAs in that area ... is it really concentrated? And do the reports that we're getting of complaints through to our Neighbourhood Enforcement Team show that there's already a situation which is beyond repair and is already a problem—which I didn't get that from looking at the Neighbourhood Enforcement Team and I don't feel looking at the immediate area around where the development site is that there is a high level of PBSAs.

 

So based on that I didn't feel that I needed to look any further at the cumulative impact. I assume that the cumulative impact for the wider area can be largely based around HMO premises. But I find it difficult to work out where do you draw the line of which area we should be looking at. In the area immediate to St. Joseph's, I don't feel that making that premises into a PBSA would significantly increase the PBSA occupation in that area.

 

17:38

Chair: Thank you very much. Mr. Anthony Draper.

 

17:44

Draper: Much weight in the officer's report has been put on the unwritten management plan to deal with noise and waste. In my statement, I provided evidence of three PBSAs in Bristol where plans have recently failed, causing health hazard and havens for vermin. Why will this unseen management plan be any different in dealing with waste and noise?

 

18:16

Officer (Dymond):  So I think you know no management plan really will be able to guarantee that there will never be any antisocial behaviour or undesirable behaviour. However, we do consider particularly having considered the the strategy that's been submitted by the applicant that a management plan could provide appropriate controls which could include a combination of on-site management arrangements, complaints procedures, liaison mechanisms, for example. It's fairly standard practice for this to be secured by condition. That's a reasonable and standard approach, and in considering any management plan we would liaise with relevant colleagues on that, also involving pollution control ,and I think it's also worth noting in relation to the management plan that the police also referenced that they considered that would be appropriate to secure that in their comments as well. So all that considered this is something that officers are recommending be secured by condition as an appropriate management tool.

 

19:41

Chair: Thank you. Do you have a second question?

 

19:43

Draper: Yes, I do. Thank you. You state in your attached police report that that provided all the available antisocial behaviour data. Beech reports, which are specific to student ASB, have not been included. Those numbers are not always visible to all police units. So they can't be guaranteed to have been included in the numbers you have. It's all student-related noise. Within the first four weeks of this term, Beech reported 38 instances of antisocial behavior.

 

20:23

Chair: Mr. Draper, can you move on, please? Because we have a limited amount of time for everyone who wants to speak.

 

Draper: When do you consider it to be harmful? -- 38 incidents, 50, 100. When does it become harmful?

 

20:40

Officer (Dymond):  In terms of the police comments, they have provided information regarding reported incidents that they have records of and they've provided that for a period of the last year. I think there is an acknowledgement though that, you know, there are other routes whereby complaints can be raised and dealt with. Of note, the police in their recent comment, and again coming back to the securing of a robust management plan, they do acknowledge the concerns that have been raised by local residents and the issues that they're aware of relating to existing student accommodation. So, it does appear that they have considered that existing situation in their comments.

 

21:42

Chair: Thank you. Charlie Draper, not present. Thank you. Oliver H.

 

21:54

Oliver H: [Indistinct] ... for the neighbouring primary school, but makes no mention of Raphael House on Hillside, home since 2002 to nine adults with learning difficulties. Their gardens would adjoin unassessed student communal space with servicing and refuse on the boundary. What assessment has been made of the impact on these residents and how has the council met its public sector equality duty in reaching this recommendation?

 

22:18

Chair:  Do you want to ... ?

 

Officer (Dhruv Raja): We did make an assessment on the impacts on Raphael Centre and that was elaborated in the September report, which is not part of this October report, but that was taken into consideration. So there is a section in the September report where we have specifically looked at if there would be any impact on Raphael Centre. To give you, like, a very brief idea about it. The site itself is quite big, and we do acknowledge that [?there] would be activities in the garden, but again as recommended by pollution control and the police those harms could be mitigated through a premises management plan. So ... we think that is sufficient enough to look at that.

 

23:00

Chair:  Do you have another question?

 

Thank you. And finally, Councillor Guy Poultney. Can I ask everyone to keep this moving, please, because we have got half an hour for everybody. So, at the moment, we're running short of time. Councillor Poultney.

 

23:15

Poultney: Thank you, Chair. The officer's report says that officers didn't identify evidence—sufficient evidence—to demonstrate a pattern of persist persistent or widespread noise. DM2 requires an assessment of whether the proposal would create or contribute towards harmful conditions. Officers concluded that it would not. They seem to have concluded that on the basis of a report from Pollution Control. And what we now know is the report from Pollution Control says that it's not possible for the council to capture the evidence that's in front of the committee that's been put there by the community. So I suppose what I'm asking is directly to Pollution Control. Is there anything in your submission to this committee that says that they're all wrong or is it just the absence of evidence that the council's failed to capture that informs the recommendation?

 

24:07

Curtis, Pollution Control: I would think I'd have to say it's the absence of evidence, which would be for many reasons why lots of people would not complain about noise, which we know historically happens. And I think in this situation, you won't get the complaints coming to the council because there's other infrastructure in place via the university and the police for the complaints to be made that way.

 

24:34

Chair: Thank you. Do you have another question, Councillor Poultney?

 

24:37

Poultney: I do. Thank you, Chair. ... It sounds like ... you have hundreds of people saying that there is existing harm, and that this will make it worse, and the council has no evidence to suggest that they're wrong. I'm wondering how it is that the officer's report is still recommending approval? On what basis are you saying they're all wrong? If Pollution Control is saying, "No, it's just the absence of evidence. We don't capture it. It says on the website, we won't look at it. Don't report it to us," then the council couldn't have that evidence, could it? So why is it that they're all wrong? And this is going to be okay?

25:22

Chair: I don't know if anyone got that, the logic of it. I don't think the council website says you shouldn't report things. It's just that we haven't had ... [someone else talking in background].

 

Curtis, Pollution Control: [Indistinct] ... the eighbourhood enforcement team noise website, or the link to it from the council website, does say that [for] a noise complaint they would want a diary kept for it and they don't deal with one-off complaints. I think what you do get often with noise [is] you get one-off complaints which become regular complaints which the neighbourhood enforcement team would be able to deal with.

 

26:06

Chair: Exactly. It's a standard procedure to have a noise diary. Everyone, every council and every ward knows what a noise diary looks like. We all have that. Yes, John.

 

26:15

Officer (Dymond):  Thank you, chair. Yeah, I think it's just important to stress as well that the officers don't dispute the residents experiencing noise and disturbance in the locality. But the planning question really in so far as this application is concerned is whether there is sufficient evidence that this particular development would create or materially worsen harmful conditions. So that's really the question in relation to this development: Is that harm that would arise from it unacceptable?

 

26:49

Chair: Thank you. We now move to statements. Is Anthony Negus here? I haven't seen him. No, I don't think so. Oh, sorry. I didn't see a hand. Oh, there you are, Anthony. Oh, nice to see you. Your statement please. Thank you.

 

27:08

Negus: Thank you. I'm aware that over considerable time a lot of good people have recognized the issues around sustaining communities in Bristol and have put a lot of time and trouble into creating rules to mitigate the problems that arise. I know this because in the thick of this I was the cabinet member responsible for planning and those rules were created then and since have been tightened up to make sure that we make the best we can for the people in this city. It surprises me therefore that there have been so many lukewarm responses to this when we have these rules: they've taken a great deal of time and trouble to put in place.

 

They're not being supported as they should. And if we don't support those rules and respect that investment of resource and time, then we are actually not supporting the purpose of this city council. And we should be seeing that instead of giving way on our own rules and representations that in that gives succour and support to people who are trying to do things which do not engage and do not represent the values of many of the people in the city council and certainly the people in the communities that are going to be affected. So I urge you please to respect that we've made democratic, legal, and crucial decisions over time to make sure that we sustain our communities in Bristol. And I'm asking that you put up a front which shows future people who may wish to subvert our rules — make sure that we put up a front which shows that we are standing firm against problems which will only make matters worse over time. This may be one building but it's 126 people who do not engage in the same way as other parts of the community. They're a temporary community and they have a different lifestyle. This makes for the community to be very damaged and it should be resisted. Please support the rules that this city council has taken a lot of time and trouble and a lot of money and resource to put in place. Thank you.

 

29:40

Chair: Derek Collier.

 

Collier: The final report claims no evidence of negative cumulative impact. This is based on statements from the police, neighbourhood enforcement team and pollution control. Yet these organizations acknowledge that their procedures do not suit the type of disturbance students make. Residents have long known this. It's why they don't bother reporting incidents to the police or the council. But there is evidence that's being ignored. In 2011, an Article 4 direction was adopted. It was a belated attempt to control the proliferation of properties being turned into student HMOs.

 

In 2020, an SPD was adopted, “Managing the development of HMOs”, a further attempt to control the number and location of student HMOs. Neither of these came out of the blue. They were prompted by pressure from local councillors and from residents. And they show that even back then the community was already suffering a negative impact. Over the years, it's only local councillors who have responded to residents’ concerns. Please listen to our local councillors. They know the scale of the issues we face.

 

30:57

Chair: Thank you. Councillor Mohamed Makawi.

 

31:04

Makawi: My name is Councillor Mohamed Makawi. I speak today both as local ward councillor for Cotham and as resident of this area. I want to make clear that neither I nor my fellow ward councillor, Guy, are opposed to student recommendation in principle. Students are [an] important part of Bristol and they contribute greatly to the life of our city. However, this application must be considered in the context of the area in which it sits. Cotham already has one of the highest concentrations of houses of multiple occupation and student accommodation in Bristol.

 

The issue before you [is] not whether student should live in Bristol but whether it is appropriate to continue concentrating ever-greater numbers of student bed spaces within a neighbourhood that is already under significant pressure. Residents have consistently raised concern about [indistinct] ...  including late-night noise, antisocial behaviour, litter, pressure on local streets, and the great gradual loss of balance and mixed community. Many resident have lived experience of this impact and have report them [?repeatedly?] over number of years. The proposal [Chair: Can you conclude please?] ... No problem ... would add 126 further student bedspaces or the area where according to the officer report [there] are already a substantial number of existing and [?consistent?] student bed space nearby. So as ward councillors we have listened carefully to our residents.

 

33:11

Chair: Can you conclude please?

 

33:14

Makawi: ... review the evidence submit, understanding why so many people object [to] this proposal. We respectfully ask the committee to give significant weight to those concerns

 

Chair: Thank you, I've asked you .. Mohamed I've asked you to conclude and you haven't; please just finish, thank you. Harriet Bradley.

 

Bradley: I've been a resident in this area for 30 years and I want to say I've simply seen urban decline as a result of the overcrowding of transient residents in the area. I have been woken I should imagine every week during the hours between 10 and 4 in the morning. It seems to me the officers who've investigated this have no understanding of student culture. They don't stay in their homes. They take to the streets. They go to parties all over the area and they create terrible noise. There are other problems that we face as residents. Car parking is extremely difficult. Students despite the fact that they don't need cars to go into work still have cars. Their families come and visit them. They have cars. Where the hell are they going to park given that Cotham Hill is already a pedestrianized area and that of course causes pollution as well as congestion. Waste is a major problem. The problem of street litter is added to the problem of students not being very good at handling the recycling processes which are quite complicated and important in Bristol. Street litter is terrible. And we have noted that it gets much better in the summer when the students aren't there. I've picked up stuff which has clearly been deposited by students and Bristol Waste can hardly cope with it. Indeed, the fact that both Whiteladies Road ... (Chair: Please conclude, Harriet.) ... I'm going to conclude. Whiteladies Road, Cotham Hill, and Chandos Road all have restaurants and bars adds to all these problems. And finally, many residents have left the area because of urban decay, and that's led to landlords buying the properties and failing to maintain them. So, they're all falling to pieces. It's shocking.

 

Chair: Thank you. Kevan Johnson-Hall and Dinah Body.

 

35.50

Cllr Serena Ralston: I speak on behalf of them, Chair.

 

Chair: Okay. Thank you. One minute, please.

 

35:57

Ralston (for others): Our neighbourhood is beyond the tipping point. Lots of data confirms this fact, but we experience it every day with our eyes and ears. Our community is struggling with the impact of the current student population. Another 126 will take us to a point where social and economic damage is hard to undo. With 126 students in St. Joseph's, we will suffer from increased street noise. Sleep isn't a gift, it's a necessity. No management plan will prevent the potential residents of St. Joseph's from being loud on the street. The area around the top of Cotham Hill and Woodland Road is often dangerous. When walking around, you have little option but to walk in the road as the students fill the pavement, spilling out from lecture theatres, with cars, vans, cycles, e-scooters also using the road. No management plan will control this. Only this committee, you the individuals that make up the committee, can save us from this unnecessary development. Please support the 162 local residents that were able to submit their objection and know that the 162 represent many more who could not voice their own opposition in this way. We are utterly and completely reliant on you, committee members, to do the right thing and turn this application down. Thank you.

 

37:05

Chair: Thank you. And now Councillor Serena Ralston.

 

37:12

Ralston: Last Wednesday night I witnessed the impact of a huge number of students on the Cotham Hill area. Rowdy drunk students crowded out the streets. This was not a one-off incident. Residents’ sleep is often interrupted so badly that they can't work the next day. Babies and young children are kept awake. Quiet enjoyment of properties is too often impossible. And this in an area that traditionally welcomes students. The St. Joseph site borders homes and Raphael House, a residential centre for those with learning difficulties. Imagine 126 more students on the street at night. No premises management plan can control this. University of Bristol received 2,625 student noise complaints between 2016 and this June. But the officers' report says that there have been just two complaints about student properties in the Cotham Hill area in five years. This clearly can't be the case. Residents have repeatedly ... (Chair: Please, we're running out of time. Can you conclude, please?) The application is contrary to NPPF policy P3, which says development should not give rise to or contribute to unacceptable levels of noise. There are 196 existing PBSA bed spaces within 200 meters of the site, [a] concentration of HMOs in the LSOA .... (Chair: Councillor Rollston, I have asked you to conclude. Please conclude.) [Ralston talking in background] [?The proposals are contrary?] to policy DM2, policy BCS18 and [the] HMO SPD. Remember, Cotham Hill is a community, not a campus. Please refuse this application.

 

[Applause]

 

38:38

Chair: 

Thank you. Due to time constraints, I'm going to have to be quite selective about who is able now to contribute to the public forum.

 

Cllr Ani Townsend: Sorry, chair. I propose that we extend public forum just due to the strength of feeling and the amount of residents that we have here.

 

[Applause]

 

38:56

Chair: Does anyone support that? Do I have a seconder for that? Richard ...

 

Eddy: I'm not proposing to second it. Clearly, we have a cooling-off procedure here. We've already had a substantial debate, substantial public forum. So frankly your job, as you know, chairman, very well, is to properly chair, properly channel the time constraints to balance [the] meeting. So, I wouldn't extend it. I'd actually maintain that, not [?indistinct] our standing orders.

 

39:41

Chair: Thank you. You are quite right actually. You're absolutely right. The rules are we have half an hour and we will have half an hour. We will not extend it. Thank you. Right, Simon Margetts and Emily Wolfe. You've not spoken before.

 

39:56

Margetts: Thank you, chair. We've lived in the area for 43 years and have witnessed the area change due to the increase in student population. Over time, quality of life has decreased. This has been due to the increase in the problems of noise disturbance, antisocial behaviour, waste disposal, fly tipping, and obstructions of the highway. That these problems are caused by students is clear as they disappear outside of term time. We're not anti-student. We've made friends of many over the years. If the high concentration in the area is a problem, adding another 126 students will only exacerbate the existing problems residents suffer. It cannot possibly improve matters. A management plan will be of no use whatsoever in controlling student behaviour outside the premises — and to suggest otherwise is ridiculous. Evidence of student concentration and the problems experienced by residents due to this is plain for the committee to see. Therefore, we urge the committee to do the right thing for the local community and reject this application.

 

40:54

Chair: Thank you. Sarah Cuthill.

 

Cuthill: Right, we're not anti-student but we feel swamped. Our street is 100 metres from St. Joseph's and it's 47% students. This is replicated over Cotham and Clifton Down. Harmful concentration results in noise including street gatherings, waste, neglect of property and no community integration. In two streets, we've had to report 96 incidents to the university in five years. We lose sleep and suffer stress. The university and Operation Beech figures make clear that there are cumulative impact issues at significant levels: 696 reports to Operation Beech in five years, 1,380 noise reports to the university. The first month of term has shown this in detail on Cotham Hill where conditions would be worsened with the addition of 126 students. There are gatherings of over 200 students on Wednesday nights. There's an average of 275 students going to lectures in a 10-minute window in the morning, filling up the streets. The application cannot offer a plan to manage students out in the community.

 

42:13

Chair: Thank you. Johnny Kidney.

 

42:17

Kidney: This scheme is not HMO. It is a managed, secure, well-contained, purpose-built student accommodation scheme with staff on site. Bristol has seen a record intake of students this year, but the provision of PBSA has not kept up with demand, adding to pressure on the unmanaged HMO sector. This exacerbates the very issues raised by residents related to HMOs and also has a knock-on impact on Bristol's well-reported housing crisis. Indeed, a recent press article suggested that the Bristol Student Union was advising new students to contact Shelter due to an acute shortage of specialist accommodation. We acknowledge the issues that exist with the unmanaged HMO sector. But where else can students go if specialist accommodation is not provided for them? There is not one single PBSA bedroom in Cotham Ward despite its proximity to campus. While there is only one other PBSA scheme in Clifton Down, where St. Joseph's is located, a modest scheme of 59 beds. Rather than an overconcentration, there is in fact an acute lack of specialist student accommodation in this area, which adds to the pressure on the HMO sector. Our proposals for St. Joseph's are an important part of the solution to these problems. Providing secure, managed, well-contained accommodation a stone throw from campus. Turning down PBSA schemes won't make students go away. They're coming to Bristol regardless. And without PBSA, this adds to the pressure for HMOs. We therefore respectfully request that members reconsider your decision of early September and resolve to grant planning permission in line with your officers' recommendation, providing managed, secure, staffed PBSA and resolving the issues about HMOS. Thank you. Thank you, committee.

 

Chair: Thank you, Johnny. Just time for Councillor George Calascione, if he's here.

 

44:11

Calascione: Yes, I'd like Councillor Guy Poultney to read out my statement and I'm still not ...

 

Chair: No, I'm afraid we haven't got time for swapping between. Can you not speak just for 30 seconds, please?

 

Calascione: He's got my statement ready to read.

 

Chair: Why haven't you got your statement?

 

Another: He's ill!

 

Calascione: Because I'm ill. I've got a sore throat.

 

44:30

Chair: Councillor Poultney, you can have 30 seconds, please, because we are already over time.

 

44:35

Poultney: Thank you for the time, Councillor Calascione. I will if it's okay take the committee through this. So, on Wednesday night, some of the councillors attended a community meeting at Redland Library. [It] finished about 10:30 and at about 10:45, we walked back up Cotham Hill [and] down Abbotsford Road. I walked down Ravenswood Road, got home at about 10:45 and on the way saw a group of students. There were 26 of them. They were going from drinking on Cotham Hill to a house party somewhere along Ravenswood Road or one of the roads off it. And they were charming. They were having a brilliant time. They were really, really lovely, vibrant young people. They were incredibly loud and I think they probably woke up every single person who was sleeping on that street. But the worst you could say was that they were just being inconsiderate. They were doing nothing that most people don't do at some point in their lives. It would have been quite a nice experience if there hadn't been another group of about the same size 5 minutes behind them, and another group behind that because on my short walk ... (Chair: Could you .... ; Poultney: .... if I may ... Chair: You may have another 15 seconds.) There were more than 14 such groups and it's noise from the street and as you said, yes, the council requires noise diaries and it specifically says on its website we will not look at noise from the street, and that's why there's no evidence that Mark [Mark Curtis, Pollution Control] could assess because the NET doesn't capture the noise that everyone is talking about. We've met with the NET. They've acknowledged that this is a problem. Mark has attended meetings with the community student partnership. So has the NET. We've raised it time and time again. Residents cannot complain about this, make the council aware of this in a way that they take into account, which is why there's such a strength of feeling. I urge the committee, please follow what your predecessor committee did. Please vote to refuse this. Thank you. Otherwise, we're accepting that council simply will not listen to the community. Thank you.

 

[Applause]

 

46:45

Chair: Thank you. And now we have a presentation from our officer. If we could maybe make it quite a brief presentation as I think we're mostly familiar with this. Is that all right? Fairly brief. Fairly brief. Thank you.

 

47:04

Officer (Dhruv Raja): Thank you, chair. Good afternoon, everyone. This application seeks permission for conversion of the former St. Josephs Care Home at Cotham Hill into a purpose-built student accommodation providing 126 student bed spaces through the refurbishment and reuse of the existing building. The application was reported to Planning Committee B on 2nd September with officer recommendation for approval. Following debate, the committee resolved to defer to seek advice on reasons of refusal on the grounds of harmful concentration of student accommodation and the cumulative effects. Officers have gone back and done the reassessment. I've also consulted the police and Pollution Control again and have reassessed and officers stand ground that the previous recommendation was sound, and officers still recommend approval. However, we've also come up with the recommended reasons of refusal for committee to review.

 

48:01

I acknowledge there are a lot of new members today, so I'll just try to briefly go over the application again so that everyone is on the same grounds. The site is a former St. Joseph's care home and convent on the northern side of Cotham Hill — as you could see, the site marked in red up there [showing Slide 3 on a big screen]. The site consists of two main buildings, a four-storey Victorian building as you could see here and a small two-storey building which was used as a laundry building. And the site consists of an extensive landscape and a big plot. The application in front [of the committee] right now talks about a purpose-built [student] accommodation within 0.56 hectares. The building was used as a care home and has been vacant since summer of 2025. It sits within the Whiteladies Road conservation area and the building is also a non-designated heritage asset and is surrounded by grade two listed buildings on Cotham Hill and on Hillside ... Hillside would be over here and Cotham House on the other side. To add to that, the site also sits at the edge of the city centre and next to the university precinct, including the Philosophy Department opposite the site, [a] primary school to the north, [and] Woodland Court PBSA, across Cotham Hill, which is situated over here. To give a better idea of the site and its context [changing to Slide 4], the buildings marked in red or orange as visible on the screen are all university buildings and are part of the university campus and the university precinct. St. Joseph's, as you could see over here, marked in red, sits exactly at the edge and very close to the university precinct.

 

49:32

Proposed development [Slide 5]: The application is for change of use from a residential institution class C2 to a purpose-built student accommodation which is sui generis. It converts both existing buildings and existing landscape and the land to student accommodation. It was submitted as 132 student bed spaces, but following discussions with officers about daylight, security and communal spaces, it was reduced to 126 bed spaces, including 99 studios, [and] 27 cluster bedrooms, with around 497 square metres of community amenity space for future residents. Officers would like to stress that this is a conversion of a vacant building and not a new development. And the development would also be providing new low-carbon heating technologies and fabric improvements to tackle climate change and sustainability issues.

 

50:23

[Slide 6] Overall, the application has attracted 174 public representations across two formal rounds of consultation. We have also received some additional objections following the committee and in the last few days. So overall we have received 171 objections and three letters of support.

 

50:43

Main issues raised are student concentration, community balance, housing mix, noise and disturbance, impact on residential amenity, impact on local character, loss of care homes and highway safety. [Slide 7] The application has also been formally objected [to] and called in by Councillor Serena Ralston and has been objected [to] by Councillor George Calascione and Councillor Guy Poultney, [who] raised similar concern as we have already heard and [were] similarly raised by the public members.

 

51:17

[Slide 8] On top of that, the application has been consulted [on] through internal consultees and external consultants as well. As you could see on screen, we haven't received any objections, including from urban design, conservation, transport development management, Avon and Somerset Police, Pollution Control, [and] Sustainability, as you could see. So we haven't received any objections subject to standard conditions which could be dealt with.

 

51:42

[Slide 9: September Committee Resolution] However, as stated, the application was brought to committee on 2nd September and the committee resolved and expressed concerns that the locality already accommodates a substantial amount of student population and existing student accommodation. The proposal would introduce a further 126 bed spaces into this area, which is a constrained area. Insufficient weight had been given to the cumulative effect of existing and proposed student accommodation and officers acknowledged that. The proposal would also undermine the maintenance of a mixed and balanced community, and the proposal would conflict with adopted policies DM2, BCS18 and with objectives of emerging policy H7. And officers were asked to come up with reasons of recommendations. Considering officers do duly respect the concerns raised by the committee, we have drafted the following reason of recommendations if members are minded to refuse the application.

 

52:37

[Slide 10: Recommended reason for refusal] In summary, it says that the extra 126 bed spaces would contribute to a harmful concentration of student accommodation in an area that is already has a substantial student population. It says that would harm community balance and residential amenity. It relies on adopted policies DM2, BCS18 and objectives of emerging policy H7 and NPPF policy P3 on living conditions and cumulative effects.

 

53:03

Officers' professional advice is still that this reason would be difficult to defend at appeal and the next three slides will explain why.

 

[Slide 11: Officer Advice]

Officers' advice is that inspectors would be likely to find against this refusal for three connected reasons. First, need. Bristol has a clear and evident need of student accommodation and national policy asks us to give it a substantial weight. Second, evidence — would be that [the] evidence before members don't demonstrate that this managed scheme would harm amenity or materially add to the harmful concentration, which is detailed out in the report. And third would be the presumption in favour of sustainable development. I would like to go through each of them a bit more in detail for members’ clarity.

 

53:47

[Slide 12: Need for Student Housing] As stated, the first reason: the council's own local housing needs assessment recognises student housing as part of Bristol's housing need. The applicants’ need assessment identifies around 59,200 full-time students in Bristol in 2024-25, which is about 28% more than in 2018-19. We can see there has been a substantial increase in student population and students coming into Bristol. The housing need forecasts around 65,900 students by 2030 and a requirement of roughly 8,800 additional bed spaces between 2023 and 2040. More than half of Bristol students, around 33,000, live outside purpose-built student accommodation, mostly in [the] private rented sector.

 

54:36

National policy is clear. Student need forms part of overall housing need under policy HO1. And H07 asks us to give substantial weight to meeting this identified need.

 

54:48

We've also tried to look at existing student accommodations in the city. We have numbers for the city centre, which is where most amount of student accommodations exist. We have 18,971 operational student accommodation, [and] 8,500 consented student bed spaces, plus 3,400 in live applications, including this one. But still officers would like to clarify this is not meeting the needs of student accommodation that we need.

 

55:18

[Slide 13: Amenity and concentration] Furthermore, looking at the main issue that we have in front of us, regarding harmful concentration ... [Talking in background. Chair: Shh, be quiet.]  .. impact on residential amenity and student concentration. I would just like to clarify in terms of planning on how do we define or how do we look at cumulative impacts. It's a combined effect of proposal together with what already exists and what has been permitted on the same area and on the same people. NPPF policy P3 and policy DM2 both require us to consider it. But the test isn't whether there are problems in the area today. It's whether this development would materially add to them, and DM2 has two limbs, which is elaborated in both committee reports. To narrow it down on the main questions that we had: Are existing conditions harmful? There's a high concentration of student population in the city, which officers fairly acknowledge, which is about 43.5% residents are full-time students. On top of that 196 bed spaces exist within 200 metres of the existing application site. Police data also show antisocial behaviour across the wider area, but it's not attributable to one source. On land use, Pollution Control accepts the noise assessment submitted by the applicant. The police acknowledge issues of noise and antisocial behaviour in the area. However, no technical objections have been raised and equally it has been difficult for Planning to link existing issues with the proposed development. The biggest challenge for Planning has been, and which officers conclude on, is that more students isn't harm by itself. Officers cannot conclude that more students in itself is a harm.

 

57:07

[Slide 14: Existing PBAs] To properly reflect student accommodations in the ward itself, as you could see here, that's Clifton Down ward — the site’s highlighted over here in red—there's scattered student accommodations across the ward.

 

57:26

[Slide 15: Presumption in Favour of Sustainable Development] Thirdly and most importantly, NPPF policy S4 states that development proposals within settlements, which is in this case, should be approved unless benefits would be substantially outweighed by any adverse effects. As you could see on screen, we have tried to weight the proposal in terms of the new NPPF. The site delivers 126 student bed spaces, which requires Planning to give substantial weight in terms of NPPF policy H07. The proposed development would be reusing a substantial vacant building, which as per policy L2 needs to be given substantial weight. The site is also going to be helping in conserving a non-heritage asset and its use for a long term, which also requires substantial weight, but as members could see, the site has a lot of benefits that needs to be given substantial weight. The issue that we have recognised and which members have also raised is additional student bed spaces in the area and the increase in student population. But as you could see it's difficult for Planning to link the issues directly with the existing issues, and we can only give it moderate weight. And the loss of [a] care home also affords some limited weight. But on balance it is difficult for planning to conclude that this development would cause any substantial harm and there are a lot of benefits that this development comes up with and which needs to be substantial weight. Thank you.

 

58:55

Chair: Thanks Dhruv. Questions from councillors, please. Make them as brief as possible and direct [to] what you actually want to know. Councillor Townsend.

 

59:07

Townsend: Hi, thank you. So I noticed that you've got the numbers of four HMOs — licensed HMOs, which I think is an important clarification — within 100 metres and 491 HMOs within the ward. Now I represent Central ward, which is just on the other side, very close by. How many HMOs are in, like, the slightly wider radius of slightly more than 200 metres, maybe three or 400 metres, taking into account Central ward, or maybe do you have the figure for how many HMOs are in that northern part of Central ward that are [in] very close proximity to this site.

 

59.24

Officer (Dymond):  I don't think we have that information available and there isn't really a policy requirement for us to look at that in the context of assessing this application. The figures that we do have, though, we feel are relevant. But in terms of that kind of wider analysis, that isn't something that policy steers us towards looking at.

 

1:00:18

Townsend: Okay. Okay. So just to so to clarify, when you're calculating how many HMOs are — and obviously you've been talking about the purpose-built student accommodation as well —you're looking at Cotham ward itself rather than the wards around it or in close proximity, like Central ward, for example, which is just on the other side of the road?

 

1:00:35

Officer (Dhruv Raja): Yes, that's correct. So we'll be looking at 100 meters, but that's for HMOS, not for purpose-built student accommodation. So the HMO SPD clearly sets out how we would be calculating HMOs, to calculate harmful concentration. But again for HMOs we would be looking at 100 metres from any site. We would also look at the ward level, but not at beyond that site.

 

1:00:57

Townsend: Okay. So as a wider thought extrapolation, so then when you're looking at the noise complaints and the waste issues and residential issues as well, you're not taking into account the wider picture of how many student numbers are in close proximity in other wards. You're just looking at the impact on that one ward for all of the issues. Is that right? Including noise complaints for example?

 

1:01:20

Officer (Dhruv Raja): So, we have taken it at two levels. So, we have taken it at the street level, which is immediately adjacent to the site, which includes 200 metres — which includes three different wards. So, we looked at the data within 200 metres and the ward itself but nothing else for this one.

 

1:01:34

Townsend: Great. So then when it's being said that there aren't any noise complaints, that's also not taking into account the ones coming from Central ward as well in that area. Is that right to assume? [Looking towards Mark Curtis, Pollution Control]

 

Curtis: That would be your right to assume that. Yes.

 

Townsend: Okay. And do you have to hand any of the numbers around noise complaints from that area?

 

Curtis: I don't. Sorry. No.

 

Townsend: Okay. I'm aware that I get quite a lot.

 

1:02:01

Chair: Would you like the figures for Avonmouth as well?

 

Townsend: Is Avonmouth in close proximity, Councillor Alexander?

 

Chair: Well, is your ward in close proximity? It depends how we define it, doesn't it? ...

 

1:02:07

Townsend: It's on the other side of the road. So yes.

 

Chair: That's why we have policy.

 

Townsend: Yes, it's on the other side of the road. So I'm just clarifying the parameters.

 

Chair: Clarifying our policies.

 

Townsend: Yes.

 

1:02:15

Chair: Thank you. Councillor Eddy.

 

Eddy: Thank you, Chair. My question to the case officer is quite simple but could I make a plea to my fellow members first. I appreciate half of us are substituting and weren't present at the last meeting but many of these questions similar to what Councillor Townsend has asked are actually raised and answered in the minutes we've just approved. So, it does require some discipline, and we did spend about an hour last time going through all those questions, which are minutely listed — both questions and answers. My question to the case officer— and it's largely rhetorical. I think I know the answer: You will be aware I asked the chief planner earlier where the NPPF sat in the hierarchy of policies and also what [the] impact would be for us of the recent planning minister's guidance. Now I assume from reading your very comprehensive report that all the reasons you came to your recommendation is based upon the NPPF which as the chief planner has said is the most recent definitive guidance. Can you confirm that please?

 

1:03:54

Officer (Dhruv Raja): Yes, that's correct. The assessment done over here is based on the new NPPF policies.

 

Eddy: Thank you.

 

1:04:00

Chief Planning Officer (Wilding): Can I just add, I would say — and maybe if you bring the green and red table up again — clearly the NPPF is absolutely important in here but actually many of the local plan policies actually go in the same direction. So, in that sense there is no question of which one overrides which one, but it's actually NPPF and local plan policies.

 

1:04:26

Chair: Thank you. Councillor Dudd, then Councillor Russell.

 

1:04:31

 

Dudd: Yeah. Thank you. My questions are around the mixed and balanced communities policies. So, we've got the figures in terms of the population numbers and the percentage of households. So, I've obviously read the report again. You've said that it doesn't reach the level where there's a significant harm. So, I'm just wondering is there a level where you would conclude that? But you also mentioned the fact that just on numbers alone it wouldn't necessarily mean that there's a harm. So, ... 60% of the population in the Lower Super Output Area could be students but from your perspective that wouldn't be a harm. It's the evidence of the harm that's important. Is that correct? Am I reading your position correctly there?

 

1:05:24

Officer (Dhruv Raja): Yes, that's correct. The difficulty that we would have is as you mentioned we don't have a specific numerical value where we could say harm is happening but we would start looking at aspects of, let's say, if there was any other type of housing being reduced or any other population that was getting reduced because of this development, then there would be ... imbalance starting to happen. But in this case, there is no loss of any other type of dwelling. There's no loss of any other type of residence going away because of this application.

 

1:05:58

Dudd: Okay. But say for example in future the population was 60% student that wouldn't breach the kind of tests if another application came forward. So there is no number.

 

1:06:10

Officer (Dymond): There isn't a set sort of threshold. And what I was just going to add there is that I think it returns back to DM2, you know, being the key relevant policy and which says that development shouldn't be permitted where the development would create or contribute to a harmful concentration where it would exacerbate existing harmful conditions. So, there is the key test about does this development, kind of based on the evidence, would it do that and again in the context of the wider policies we've talked about as well in terms of the new NPPF and that requirement for there to be, kind of, evidence of substantial harm, significant harm occurring.

 

1:06:56

Dudd: Okay. And what would that harm be? Because obviously we've heard about noise complaints and I've got my own experience of witnessing the kind of straining infrastructure in the area. So, if you look at St. Michael's Hill, for example, at peak times, when you've got like hundreds of students walking on really narrow pavements and walking into the road, for example. So, I think that's a ... harm, you know, not having those numbers without the infrastructure in place. So, ... what would we class as a harm that would meet that test?

 

1:07:31

Officer (Dymond): Yeah, I mean we certainly have regard to the representations received and have noted the issues that have been raised through that. On the infrastructure point, and you know, movement issues, we can probably say a little bit more about that because there is some proposal to provide some mitigation within the vicinity of the site. Is it worth just bringing that up DR? ... We've just got a plan showing some proposed works that we can say a bit about.

 

1:08:02

Dudd: Yeah, I saw this last time [Slide 30: Highway Works under Section 278 Agreement]. I don't think there's a big problem at this junction. Obviously, there probably is a problem, but it's not as big as some of the other locations within a vicinity of this proposed site. And a solution there would cost millions, probably, to have the adequate infrastructure in place to cope with the numbers. So, I guess it would be wrong to put all the emphasis on this scheme. But in more general, what are we doing to get the university to step up, because they're causing this impact on the infrastructure? What are they doing in terms of financial contribution to some of the problems that we see with the road infrastructures? So, I think, really, St. Michael's Hill probably needs to be either pedestrianised or have a sort of a low-traffic scheme introduced there to cope with the numbers, really. So, what ... are the university doing about— what are we doing about it — to demand that the money gets put on the table to deal with some of these problems? So, I think a lot of the issues that we've heard [indicates public gallery], you know, they probably won't stem from this scheme. It's about all the stuff that's there already, the problems we're hearing about. And what will we be doing about it?

 

1:09:18

Officer (Dymond): Sorry, councillor. In assessing this scheme and obviously securing appropriate mitigation, we can only do that in so far as it's kind of in proportion and in scale, sort of, to this scheme, but I don't know if colleagues can maybe add anything just in terms of those wider issues that you've mentioned.

 

1:09:36

Officer (Jane?): Yeah, no, I understand and dealt with the university's application for the library building, which is still valid, and we secured some money towards the [CIL ?] — you might remember back in the day, to — but generally it would be because it's sort of [a] wider strategic issue, it would be a sort of CIL resourcing issue. So, it's, yeah, there's been a lot of university development that will have paid a lot of money towards CIL. So, it's just making sure if that is [a] priority for members, that is included, that sort of those sort of measures are included in the CIL recommendations. So, but generally, it would be more strategic looking at it, rather than each individual development. No, I very much appreciate where you're coming from.

 

1:10:22

Chair: Yeah, it's disappointing that library hasn't gone ahead and there was a lot of good things planned for the area. Maybe it's a wider subject we could deal with at economy and skills committee at some point. Yes, Councillor Russell.

 

1:10:37

Russell: Hi. Yeah, I have a couple of concerns ... and I'm wondering if they could be addressed by adding in conditions. So first of all, is around the PBSA just being for first-years. I think there was a resident who stated in his statement that this just exacerbates the issue of second- and third- years moving out after that first year. So, I was wondering if it would be possible to put in a condition for it to be not just for first-years — for it to be mixed. I didn't know if that's something that could be done, because that, yeah would ...

 

Chair: I defer to officers, but I suggest it's probably where one's sort of entering into the territory of the business plan of the developer rather than a planning condition. Officers?

 

1:11:31

Officer (Dymond): I mean, initial reaction to that really is that's an operational matter. I think that would probably fall outside the scope of what we could reasonably control through a planning condition.

 

1:11:42

Russell: Okay. Thank you. Yeah. I think you'll probably have the same response to my second one then, which was around whether we could suggest that a number of the rooms or yeah, spaces, within the PBSA could be affordable as Bristol is the most expensive city to be a student in the UK. But I expect it's the same sort of area.

 

1:12:04

Officer (Dymond): Well, on that, I mean, of note is the hopefully soon-to-be-adopted new local plan, which includes a new policy, H7. As it stands, obviously, given the stage that's at, as was mentioned earlier, we still await to hear from the inspector as to whether that will actually be sort of taken forward into the plan that is ultimately adopted. But there is an intention there for affordable student accommodation to be secured sort of through that, but obviously with the caveat that it's kind of subject to sort of formal adoption.

 

1:12:39

Russell: Thank you.

 

Chief Planning Officer (Wilding): I think just to clarify, though, because it's not adopted yet we can't put weight on it now and hence we can't insist on it in this application. In future applications, we could.

 

Chair: But it's a discussion local councillors might like to have with the applicant, you know. Not everything has to happen in here, you know. Anything further before we move to discussion? Well then, let's move to the discussion. First one, hand up, please. Well, that's Councillor Townsend. Okay, then Councillor Freeman.

1:13:19

Townsend: Thank you. I know you love ...

 

Chair: [Indistinct] it's going to be a short discussion there but ...

 

Townsend: Just to start, I'm kind of mindful of your comments about predetermination which is why myself and my colleagues have all subbed in this time round to ensure that, and also I'm mindful that we are all new on this particular application, but I'm sure, like myself, we've all watched the previous committee and also read the minutes, as yourself and comrade Eddy have suggested that we should have, and I can assure you that we have. I've got a lot of experience of this particular neck of the woods. I used to live in this area many years ago, or represent the other side of the ward, which is Central ward, and I know that there is actually a huge amount of student accommodation there, as Councillor Dudd has alluded to as well. And I know he's got personal experience from when he was ward councillor that there are some streets around here that are three-quarters, at least, student HMOs.

 

1:14:18

The high proportion of student numbers in this area, it is already very damaging. And it's really hard to see how this can satisfy DM2 to avoid sort of harm for concentrations of specialist accommodation, because already it's a very high rate of student accommodation. It may not be purpose-built, but there is a huge amount in that area. There isn't a mixed and balanced community. Shops in the local vicinity struggle when it's not term time. The roads struggle when it is term time. When the students are all changing over their classes at the same time, it's dangerous around there because the roads are busy. There's cars everywhere. There's the public transport. There's students. The pavements aren't wide enough and there's not enough road space to make the pavements any wider, either.

 

1:15:08

I'm very conscious of all the representation about the noise. When I lived around there 20 years ago, it was pretty bad and it's gotten worse in the 20 years since. So, in terms of having looked and watched the previous committee that discussed this in detail, having listened to public forum again and having listened to the officer recommendations and presentation today, I just I cannot see how anything in this application satisfies DM2, BCS18, H7 and P3 of the national framework. It's just not satisfying any of those things. And I think all the objections and reasons that this was rejected last time round still stand. And I haven't heard anything that can convince me otherwise. There's no conditions that we can put on that can say otherwise, either. So, I cannot vote for this. I'm going to have to vote to reject this and follow the lead of the previous committee.

 

[applause from public gallery]

 

1:16:13

Chair: Councillor Eddy. Oh, sorry Councillor Freeman—I missed—and then Councillor Eddy.

 

1:16:23

Freeman: Thank you. Yeah, obviously I'm new to this. It's not my patch. I don't have the same experience as some of the people. I happen to be a student but not living in a PBSA. I'm really I think you know there's some stuff here around reusing a really large building which obviously is a huge part of that area and it needs something doing to it and I would want it to be preserved and made more sustainable and to last. It'd be awful to see it go to rack and ruin.

 

1:16:59

I am very concerned about this balance of the community though. I think a lot of communities struggle with balance anyway. Even in South Bristol, we have people unhappy about their streets being more HMO or more student — and not even student, but just that sort of transient nature of people that come in and aren't there for any length of time. And the fact that this area already has a huge number of HMOs is obviously a concern. I recognize that this is a different type of accommodation — it’s managed PBSA — but I think in terms of the impact it has on the area that's not going to make enough difference. I think it's very difficult because of this reporting issue that we've got where we can't really get a proper handle on what the impact is of students outside of the kind of parameters of where things can be reported. So, we can't get a proper handle on noise on the street. We can't get a proper handle on what is ... the harm that we've talked about. And I recognise that students themselves are not harmful, and I think many people have said they're not anti- student. It's just this cumulative effect of having that particular type of population within the community that's causing issues. I'm minded to vote against, but I can see that this is a really difficult one and I understand why officers are continuing to hold their position. But I think as Ani has alluded to, there's no shift here from the previous concerns that were raised. So, I can't see that there's enough different in this application to change what this committee should do.

 

[applause from public gallery]

 

1:18:46

Chair: Thank you, Councillor Eddy.

 

Eddy: I will seek not to actually repeat what I said last time. We have in St. Joseph’s home a locally listed historic asset which I believe the applicant has designed and through the negotiations with officers improved their offer and I believe it's a very sympathetic development. We're not talking about family homes being set aside for PBSA. We're talking of actually an institution, of course, which has to be invested in, otherwise it will fall to pieces and it would be a crime to actually do that to a historic building [in] a key part of Bristol when we have such an acute housing crisis not only for the [?settled] community but students, of course. I would like to go quickly back to actually what Mr. Kidney said about the national coverage, newspaper coverage, only a few days after our last meeting, and the Daily Telegraph actually there stated that because of the student accommodation crisis in Bristol, of so many new students approaching halls of residence being told there weren't sufficient facilities, the student union had actually recommended anyone who were [indistinct] [to] contact the homeless charity Shelter.

 

1:20:44

Now all of us know the depth of the housing crisis in this city and the 1,700 people who are homeless who we have a statutory homeless duty for. There are many more we know who live in overcrowded accommodations. So we need to address this. But I find it shameful that we're actually pushing students to go to Shelter in this situation. That does seem criminal. I also actually — I'm long enough in the tooth in this chamber to remember plenty of members who've made I think very courageous decisions not necessarily paying to galleries or whatever but acting on principle and they resign from the cabinet, they lost money [and] political influence, and I actually think in comparison with that it would be appalling and disgusting for members of this committee not to do what we are elected to do, what we are put here to do, which is to assess planning obligations according to policies. We've heard the weight we need to give to the NPPF etc. And that falls very much behind the case officer's recommendation today. And actually, it too is not a material consideration, we know, but it's factor to actually reject a planning application we know in planning terms is fully acceptable, and if it's refused will go to actually appeal, most likely [to] be overturned and costs awarded against us, and sadly I wish it was actually the costs were paid by the councillors who voted it down, but no it goes — it's not the planning budget — often we have to corporally address it. So, it's the taxpayers of Bristol out there who have to pay. And I personally find that really sticks in the craw. It isn't a moral position. It's not a courageous position. It's pandering, frankly. So, I'll be voting for this.

 

1:23:25

Chair: Thank you, Richard. And I'm not at all frightened to admit when I agree with you. And I would add that to leave a historic building like this without a purpose and to build something else to house those people — and they are people — which inevitably will happen. We're always talking about recycling and reusing as the first thing that we should do with the environment in the state it is. And buildings are the first thing on the list that should be reused whenever possible. We shouldn't have to build another building for 180 people because we don't want to use this building there for anything. Councillor Russell.

 

1:24:18

Russell: Yeah, hi. A couple of things. First of all, I did want to point out that alternative use is not a material consideration. So, what else this building could be isn't something that really should be discussed in this conversation. I also wanted to come back to my concerns from before, because obviously students are a very vulnerable population and we should be doing everything to prevent homelessness and help them. But I'm not convinced that this would do that. I think that voting for this would just enable the unsustainable expansion of the universities. Yeah, for me to be able to support a PBSA, it would have to give me confidence that it would be affordable, that it would be for mixed ages, which this is not. So, I will be voting against it. Thank you.

 

1:25:04

Chair: Councillor Maghrabi.

 

1:25:12

Maghrabi: Thank you. I might just like to say that Bristol needs student housing as the number of students continues to expand but I also think that it has to be done in a way that's actually fair to the communities that they’re being housed amongst and not to the detriment of them. I believe that the concentration of student accommodation and like HMOs in the area has [?impacted] it and I also think that this development will add to the cumulative impact to the area. I also think that the university should like stop taking on more student if they don't have the like houses and places for these students, and I think ultimately it's their responsibility to make sure that they like have that sorted and if they don't, then they should just stop taking on more students. Thank you.

 

[applause from public gallery]

 

1:27:56

Chair: Thanks. Councillor Durston. Don't feel you have to comment if you don't want to, but thank you. It's difficult to add to some of the contributions that have already been made.

 

Durston: I’ll just be short. Yeah. So, I do think that what we've got today is basically a balancing exercise between what we know is a need in Bristol for PBSA and in this case the reuse of an existing building with concerns about the cumulative impact of student concentration and the impact then that has on the balance of the community. I do really hear the concerns that everyone has brought along here today. I also have lived around this area myself longer ago than I would like to share with everyone. But so I am really familiar with the issues around there. But I do think they speak as well to a wider issue that we have around the way that the university is expanding and their contributions into infrastructure and supporting that expansion. At the same time, I understand from the previous planning committee that I was on where we looked at this application that alternative uses for this building are very limited, and I did support the officer recommendation last time. I don't feel that today the planning balance has been tipped in the other direction. So, I am minded to support the officer recommendation here today.

 

1:29:33

Chair: Thank you. Councillor Dudd.

 

1:29:36

Dudd: Thank you. Yeah, I'm quite torn by this one actually, because I think the use of the building is fine. I support that. It's just the context which it's in. And I'm not convinced that over recent years — or I haven't seen any plans that convince me that the university can step up to the required level to provide the infrastructure that's needed for the increasing numbers that we've seen on the slide there that are coming forward over the next 10 years or so. So, I was just wondering, would it be possible to condition that the funding we've secured for transport mitigation is used on St. Michael's Hill and mitigating the problem there? So, I believe that's where the greater need is in terms of mitigation.

 

1:30:27

Chair: It's not what we as an organization have asked for, that's the problem. And would it be sufficient — Jane?

 

1:30:35

Officer (Jane?): Yeah, it wouldn't cover — I think in the absence of funding from elsewhere that would be quite — it just wouldn't be spendable. But we had specific safety related problems associated with that junction, in terms of crossing and the widths of crossing and footways around there. So, we would be seeking to address those site-specific issues for this site-specific problem, I'm afraid.

 

1:30:59

Dudd: So, I guess from my point of view then, I don't see where the funding's coming from to deal with or to mitigate these issues of the increasing numbers. So, I don't think I could support the application today on that basis.

 

[applause from public gallery]

 

 

1:31:13

Chair: Council Townsend

 

Townsend: I just wanted to echo what Kai said about, yeah, St. Michael's Hill, and then also throw into the mix as well: Ideally, if this did get given permission at some point, if it's today or another time, that improved traffic safety at the Woodlands Road/Tyndalls Park junction as well, that's incredibly dangerous.

 

1:31:42

Chair: Can we not discuss the transport problems of the area, because it's not relevant to the application that we are now discussing?

 

1:31:50

Townsend: I feel like it's incredibly, actually — if there's something that we could condition to it, if it were to pass, I think it would be important.

 

1:31:55

Chair: We can't. We have already asked from the applicant certain things to mitigate particular safety problems, and the wider problems of the area, whilst they may be very real, are not pertinent to this particular application, cannot be fixed by this application, and are not good reason to refuse this application. That's the point.

 

1:32:16

Townsend: Disagree entirely, chair but ...

 

Chair: I know you will. I know you will. Yes. Shall we — can someone propose the officer recommendation please? Thank you. I will propose it. Richard, would you like to second it? Okay. The officer recommendation is to approve. So,

 

[roll call]

 

Eddy: For

Russell: Against

Maghrabi: Against

Townsend: Against

Freeman: Against

Durston: For

Dudd: Against

Alexander: For

 

That leaves us as having refused it. [Chair talks to Officer Dymond]

 

1:33:12

Townsend: Can I propose a motion to reject the application?

 

Chair: No, you can't.

 

1:33:17

Townsend: That, no, because to follow process, that's what we need to do.

 

Chair: No, I'm speaking to officers and I want to come back to you in a moment. I have a right to speak to an officer a second. [Delay during sidebar] Very good. Okay. Officers have obviously as part of the third time of bringing this back given us reasons that they would consider the most credible ones for refusal and that is in paragraph 60. So, we will now vote on refusal with those reasons. Does anyone wish to second that? Councillor Townsend, okay. So we will refuse and the reasons are given in paragraph 60.

 

[roll call]

 

Eddy: Against

Russell: For

Maghrabi: For

Townsend: For

Freeman: For

Durston: Against

Dudd: For

Alexander: Against

 

So that is okay. So, there's one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. So, that's five for and three against. So, the officer recommendation is rejected. [applause]  I think we will take 10 minutes and meet at quarter to 4 please for the next application.

####

 

Comments


Free Newsletter

Want to stay up to date? It's easy—just take a few seconds to sign up to my email list.  I send out a periodic e-bulletin summarising recent news. I may also send brief alerts if there's an important development.

 

There are about 370 subscribers as of October 2023. Join them—and encourage me to keep going!  

Comments? Questions? Want to report noise?

Let me know what you think!. Please email thenoisepages@gmail.com.

I will get back to you as soon as possible. If you'd like to send me a comment for publication, make it clear you'd like me to post it.

bottom of page