My submission on HMO concentration
This is the full text of a late submission I uploaded to the planning website on 12 October 2026, before the second meeting on 14 October. I had published an article on The Noise Pages and wanted to ensure the planning team were aware of it. I also wanted to ensure it was included with the documents that would be sent to an inspector in the event of an appeal.
---------------
The following is submitted as an additional comment in response to the officers' reports to the September and October meetings of Planning Committee B.
I suggest that assessments of whether a harmful concentration of HMOs exists in the area near the proposed St Joseph's development failed to adequately consider the "neighbourhood" test required by Policy DM2 and therefore missed clear signs that such a concentration exists.
DM2 does not provide a specific mechanism for the tests it requires at street, neighbourhood or ward levels. At the September meeting, an officer provided a ward-level assessment using the 10% guideline introduced by the HMO supplementary planning document adopted in 2020. This is a sensible-enough solution. The HMO SPD said a density of 10% HMOs is "considered a likely tipping point, beyond which negative impacts to residential amenity and character are likely to be experienced and housing choice and community cohesion start to weaken".
The percentage is derived by dividing the total number of HMOs in the area under consideration by the total number of dwellings (including the HMOs).
The officer also conducted a test by drawing a circle of 100 metres radius from the centre of the St Joseph's site. This borrows the "neighbourhood" test that the SPD introduced for assessment of HMO applications. Applied to an HMO site, which would usually be the size of a single house, such a circle would take in several streets, thus representing the neighbourhood. However, this rule cannot plausibly be applied to St Joseph's. First, the application is for PBSA, not an HMO, so applying the 100m method to the site confuses two separate assessment methodologies.
("Emerging policy H7 stipulates a 200m circle for PBSA assessments.) Second, the St Joseph's site is so large that it filled much of the 100m circle itself. The circle covered only a small area outside the site. This cannot reasonably be regarded as a suitable neighbourhood test in the current case.
As a result, a realistic neighbourhood assessment was not performed in the September presentation. (Other than the ward level test, no suitable neighbourhood or street level test was done, since the 100m-circle approach satisfied neither.)
The following analysis addresses that omission by using the Cotham Hill Lower Super Output Area as a suitable proxy for the "neighbourhood". It is smaller than a ward but bigger than a street, and matches reasonably closely to the area of concern around St Joseph's.
I assess HMO density using the same approach that the planning officer at September's meeting considered reasonable for his ward-level calculation.
Not having access to the full range of tools available to planning officers, my count of HMOs in the LSOA is necessarily limited to a careful hand-count of HMOs visible on the council's Pinpoint map in relation to the LSOA boundary. I sourced the number of dwellings from a 2026 database of LSOA data shown on the gov.uk website.
The resulting calculation shows an HMO density of 14%, which exceeds the 10% threshold. It's likely that the true percentage of HMOs is somewhat higher, because planning officers would normally also include data relating to some properties that are not shown on the map.
I have published the full analysis, and supporting notes, on this web page: https://www.thenoisepages.com/single-post/the-data-that-shows-14-hmo-concentration
Comments